Some of the links on our blog are affiliate links. Should you buy using our links, we might receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more here. All opinions expressed by contributors are solely their own.
College Guide Pro caught our attention because of its promise: affordable courses and support focused on lowering tuition costs. It looks great. However, upon closer examination, you’ll notice that it’s actually a bit too light. So, in this College Guide Pro review, we’ll give you the full scoop on their services and what prospective students should consider before signing up for these courses.
When the goal is to choose the right college, secure financial aid, or manage the complexities of applications, it’s especially important to know if a service truly delivers on its promises.
Pros & Cons of College Guide Pro
The following breakdown of the main pros and cons of College Guide Pro will help you decide if its services are worth the investment.
| ➕ PROS | ➖ CONS |
|---|---|
| This company focuses on lowering the net cost of college (financial aid, scholarships, and offer appeals). | The CollegeGuidePro.net website lacks detailed descriptions of specific services, which may confuse potential clients. |
| College Guide Pro offers an affordable, online-first model with tools, masterclasses, and weekly Q&A for ongoing help. | College Guide Pro experts don’t guarantee admission or financial aid outcomes. |
| A good fit for families who want structured guidance without high consulting fees. | Lighter on intensive 1:1 counseling and essay coaching than traditional consultants. |
If your goal is to understand college costs better, College Guide Pro may offer you a few pointers. But if you’re serious about getting accepted into competitive schools and want expert-level support, this platform falls short. They seem more interested in getting you to sign up than in providing high-quality consulting.
And to make things worse, their website, CollegeGuidePro.net, feels unreliable and poorly maintained, which doesn’t inspire much confidence.
In summary, if you’re serious about getting into a good college, CollegeGuidePro.net might not be your best bet. There are far more transparent, experienced, and student-focused consulting options available.
What Are The Main Admission Consulting Services of College Guide Pro?
College Guide Pro markets itself as a college planning and financial savings platform.
Founded by Michael MacKelvie, this company offers affordable college planning services as an alternative to traditional admissions consulting. They claim to reduce costs by 70-80% compared to traditional advising services.
In theory, the platform focuses on lowering the net cost of college rather than improving a student’s admission outcomes. That can be useful, but it’s important to remember that cost-saving and college admissions are two very different skill sets.
Additionally, many of their services lack depth. For example, CollegeGudePro promotes assistance with financial aid. Still, their information on the types of aid available is not detailed enough, which could leave families feeling uninformed about their actual options. Just look at PrincetonReview.com to get a good example.
What’s Included in Those Packages?
College Guide Pro divides its offerings into three main components:
- College Planning Tool – a software that compares schools’ net prices, scholarships, and financial aid options.
- College Savings Masterclasses – a set of cinematic video courses for parents and students, promising to “unlock 100+ savings strategies.”
- Expert Guidance – weekly Q&A sessions and occasional one-on-one consultations with “college planning experts,” some of whom are said to include Ivy League financial aid officers and Certified Financial Planners.
While this sounds comprehensive on paper, the experience often feels more like a self-guided financial planning course than personalized admissions support. Most interactions happen in group settings or pre-recorded videos. And though their website mentions one-on-one consultations, these come at an extra cost.
So, while College Guide Pro talks about helping students “get into college,” the real service they’re pushing is learning how to pay less, not necessarily how to get accepted.
Who Is on the College Guide Pro Team (Are They Knowledgeable Enough)?
The team at College Guide Pro claims to consist of College Planning Consultants and Certified Financial Planners. But simply holding a title doesn’t equate to quality guidance. The profiles of their team members are not readily available, which is concerning.
Families who want to hire college advisers need to know much about the consultants’ past work and how well they help students get into college. Without this information, it’s hard to trust they have the necessary experience to guide students through the competitive admissions process.
And as mentioned earlier, the company is led by Michael MacKelvie, who brings a financial planning background. He’s experienced with money management, but his credentials are not in college admissions.
On top of that, Michael MacKelvie now seems focused on other projects (as seen on his YouTube channel), so College Guide Pro’s mission feels a bit pushed to the side.
Do They Offer Any Extra Services?
College Guide Pro highlights bonus features like financial aid appeal templates and access to “office hours” with college experts. It seems to be helpful, but these options don’t replace the value of consistent one-on-one support.
By the way, Prep Expert includes these as part of their standard offerings, making College Guide Pro’s “extras” feel more like an attempt to boost revenue than to provide real value.
Does CollegeGuidePro.net Have Any FREE Services?
CollegeGuidePro occasionally promotes free webinars or sample videos, but these work primarily as marketing tools rather than genuine learning resources. All visitors are quickly funneled toward signing up for a paid plan.
CollegeGuidePro Pricing and Guarantees
College Guide Pro offers three pricing tiers:
- Monthly Plan – $79 monthly for 12 months, totaling $948. This plan includes access to planning tools, masterclasses, and weekly Q&A sessions.
- Saver Plan – a one-time payment of $697, providing the same services as the Monthly Plan but at a lower cost.
- Pro Plan – pricing varies and includes personalized planning sessions.
While these options may seem affordable, the services provided lack depth. Their guarantees are also vague. Experts at College Guide Pro don’t promise admission results, improved financial aid, or even personal feedback timelines.
There’s also a 14-day refund policy, but given the vague service descriptions and the self-service nature of the product, families often realize too late that what they paid for doesn’t match their expectations.
Their Professionalism in Terms of College Guide Pro Reviews
CollegeGuidePro.net showcases only positive testimonials, creating an impression of satisfied customers.
Outside of their own site, feedback is surprisingly minimal. Major review platforms such as Trustpilot currently have little to no detailed College Guide Pro reviews. On Facebook, the company’s page has limited engagement and almost no substantial user feedback.
Even on Reddit, where parents and students often share candid opinions about college prep services, College Guide Pro is barely mentioned.
This lack of verified feedback makes it difficult to trust the company’s transparency and credibility.
Areas of College Guide Pro That They Should Work On
College Guide Pro makes plenty of big promises, but there’s still significant room for improvement. The areas that need the most attention include:
- Admissions depth is lacking. The focus on financial savings overshadows a full admissions strategy.
- Limited 1:1 access. Many features are self-service or group-based, and individualized attention appears to come at extra cost.
- There is no independent feedback. CollegeGuidePro has posted numerous testimonials on its website, but the absence of broad, independent feedback raises concerns about transparency. We’d like to see more College Guide Pro reviews.
- Team transparency is weak. The credentials of admissions-specific experts are not clearly documented publicly.
- Founder distraction. The founder’s move to other projects might make you wonder if they’re still fully committed to the main service.
Our Verdict
So, College Guide Pro seems to be legit, but legitimacy doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the right choice. It comes across more like a financial planning tool dressed up as a college service. Add in the clunky website, unclear team details, and a founder who seems focused elsewhere. It’s hard to feel confident about its future.
For those primarily seeking financial planning assistance, it may have some value. But if you want a personalized admissions strategy or in-depth support, you’ll likely find stronger, more transparent options elsewhere.
❓ FAQs
How much does CollegeGuidePro services cost?
College Guide Pro charges about $79 per month for 12 months or a one-time payment of around $697 for access to its courses, planning tools, and live sessions.
Is College Guide Pro a reputable company?
College Guide Pro is a legitimate business, but its reputation is mixed. While its own site highlights positive testimonials, independent reviews are minimal, making its overall credibility hard to gauge.
Can CollegeGuidePro.net guarantee acceptance?
No. The company does not guarantee admission to any college or university. Its services mainly focus on helping families save on tuition and understand financial aid.
Is College Guide Pro legit?
Yes, it’s a legitimate platform, but not a full-service admissions consulting firm. It works more like a college financial planning tool than a hands-on admissions program.
Is College Guide Pro worth it?
It may be worth trying for families who want basic financial guidance on college costs, but those seeking personalized admissions help will likely find better options elsewhere.