Some of the links on our blog are affiliate links. Should you buy using our links, we might receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more here. All opinions expressed by contributors are solely their own.
If you’re searching for a college admissions consultant, it’s better to know which services deliver real value. In this College Inroads review, I’ll share my experience with their services and why I believe future students and parents should be cautious before committing.
From lackluster consulting to steep prices, there are several red flags that anyone considering their services should know.
Pros & Cons of College Inroads
Here’s what you need to be aware of before making your decision.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| College Inroads offers a customized 16-step plan that helps students through the college application process from start to finish. | While they serve a wide area, including the U.S., Mexico, and Canada, students outside these regions may benefit less from their services. |
| They emphasize helping families find the most affordable college options, taking into account financial aid opportunities and budget considerations. | Some students prefer more self-directed approaches to college planning, while the guidance offered by College Inroads might feel restrictive. |
| The team assists with applications, essay writing, and financial aid forms, offering support at every stage. | Professional counseling services like those offered by College Inroads can be expensive. |
In my professional opinion, College Inroads is not worth the investment. While they may be helpful to some, the risk of being left high and dry, as others have experienced, is too great. They need to improve their follow-up process, offer more value for the price, and guarantee results before I recommend them.
Better and more reliable options exist for families looking for real, tangible help with the college application process.
What Are the Main Admission Consulting Services of College Inroads?
CollegeInroads advertises itself as a one-stop shop for everything college admissions-related. They claim to offer everything from helping students pick the right schools to guidance with essay writing and even interview prep.
On the surface, this sounds promising, but in my opinion, the execution is lacking.
What’s Included in Their Packages?
Their 16-step process includes the expected services:
- SAT/ACT preparation.
- Essay writing assistance.
- Financial aid applications.
- School comparisons.
While these are undoubtedly useful, from what I know, these services are pretty basic and lack any real depth. You can find similar help in free online communities and even at your local high school’s counseling office.
The so-called “comprehensive” packages lack essential features that most other consulting firms offer as standard. For example, while Admissionado gives students unlimited access to essay revisions, College Inroads caps this, often leaving students scrambling to get the help they need before deadlines.
Who Is On Their Team? Are They Knowledgeable Enough?
College Inroads presents a team that appears qualified at first glance.
For example, Annmarie Hatfield and Mike Davila are prominently featured. However, in my personal experience, and from what I see on sites like Yelp and Reddit, many parents feel the team doesn’t truly deliver on their promises.
As I know from general practice, admissions consultants should have current, firsthand knowledge of college admissions trends, but the advice students receive here feels outdated.
Does CollegeInroads.com Offer Any Extra Services?
College Inroads does offer a few extra services, such as helping with scholarships and financial aid forms. However, these services aren’t anything special. Many families who have used their consulting financial assistance mentioned that they could have easily found the same information with a quick Google search.
When paying premium prices, you expect insider knowledge that adds value, not easily accessible information anyone could find.
Do They Have Any FREE Services?
If you’re looking for free resources, don’t expect much. Unlike Admit Advantage, which offers helpful content for those who might not be able to afford the full packages, CollegeInroads provides very little.
There are a couple of generic articles on their website and occasional social media posts, but nothing that helps students and parents.
Their Pricing and Guarantees
One of the most frustrating aspects of College Inroads is the lack of transparency regarding pricing. This firm doesn’t provide a price list on the official website, which is a significant disadvantage. You must schedule a consultation to find out the exact cost of their packages.
At the same time, one Yelp review by John S. from San Francisco mentioned that after paying over $4,000 for their services.
Worse, CollegeInroads.com doesn’t offer any guarantees. I understand that no one can guarantee admission to a top school, but at the very least, families deserve some form of reassurance that their investment will yield real results.
Their Professionalism in Terms of Reviews Available Online
College Inroads has a very mixed reputation online. Some, like Austin S., rave about how the team helped their children get thousands in scholarships and guided them toward engineering programs.
However, these glowing reviews are often outweighed by the negative ones. For instance, John S.’s review, in which he felt abandoned close to the deadline, indicates a worrying trend of inconsistency and unprofessionalism.
Areas of College Inroads That Need Work
Now, let’s address the five areas where College Inroads needs the most improvement:
- Personalization – their advice is generic and doesn’t cater to the specific needs of students.
- Knowledge – the consultants at CollegeInroads.com don’t seem to have up-to-date knowledge of admissions trends, and their advice often feels outdated.
- Pricing – their services are overpriced for the value they provide.
- Essay help – this company limits the number of essay revisions, leaving students without the necessary support before deadlines.
- Communication – many families have reported long response times and unprofessional communication.
In conclusion, CollegeInroads.com may seem like a good option for families looking for college admissions help, but in my opinion, their service doesn’t live up to the hype.
❓ FAQs
How much does it cost to use College Inroads services?
College Inroads’ services range from a few hundred dollars for basic packages to several thousand for more comprehensive ones. However, many clients feel the pricing doesn’t reflect the value they receive.
Is College Inroads a reputable company?
College Inroads has mixed reviews online. While they market themselves as experts in college admissions, many clients report dissatisfaction with their services, citing outdated advice and a lack of personalized support.
Can CollegeInroads.com guarantee acceptance?
No, College Inroads does not and cannot guarantee college acceptance. Like any admissions consultant, they offer guidance, but there are no guarantees regarding college admissions.
Is College Inroads legit?
College Inroads is a legitimate business, but the quality of their services is often questioned. While some clients may have had positive experiences, numerous online reviews suggest their services don’t deliver the expected results.